Topical Studies
What the Bible says about
What Does ' Discerning the Lord's Body' Mean?
(From Forerunner Commentary)
|
1 Corinthians 11:20-22
While the Passover is an annual observance—happening just once each year—the issue here is the congregation occasionally gathering as a church for a meal. The text implies that their "com[ing] together as a church" was a frequent occurrence rather than an annual one. The event he speaks of, then, was not the Passover, despite his mentioning it in the midst of his admonition. The congregational gathering was an occasion for food, fellowship, and fun—perhaps akin to the "love feasts" of Jude 12. Yet we can tell that Paul took great exception to what occurred during those feasts because his admonition is quite stern. He describes blatant self-centeredness, lack of self-control, and general despising of God's church through some shaming and despising others on account of their personal situations. Following this, in verses 23-26, the apostle brings up the Passover for a couple of reasons. First, some were confused, thinking that any church gathering was a time to commemorate the Passover. Thus, Paul had told them in verse 20 that when they came together, it was not to eat the Lord's Supper. He feels a need to give them a brief refresher on what the Passover is. Second, the Passover is a powerful, motivational teaching tool to get his point across about their shortcomings. So, in verse 27, he underscores the matter's seriousness: "Therefore whoever eats this bread or drinks this cup of the Lord in an unworthy manner will be guilty of the body and blood of the Lord." We must understand this is within the context of their behavior in the congregation, where some were only looking out for their own interests, and others were being despised and shamed. That context does not end until the chapter's end in verse 34. The apostle is warning them about taking the Passover while they continued to perpetrate this social and spiritual violence against their brethren. Observing the Passover in such an unworthy way will make an offender guilty of Christ's body and blood. This matter of worthiness is so crucial that he instructs church members to perform an examination—an evaluation—of our spiritual state before we partake of the Passover: "But let a man examine himself, and so let him eat of the bread and drink of the cup" (I Corinthians 11:28). God will not look favorably on those who mistreat the ones for whom Christ died.
David C. Grabbe
What Does 'Discerning the Lord's Body' Mean? (Part One)
|
|
1 Corinthians 11:27-29
The apostle Paul tells the Corinthians that when it came time to take the Passover, they were in danger of eating and drinking judgment to themselves. Why? It was not that they were somehow failing to appreciate Jesus Christ's physical body, but because they were not being partial to His spiritual Body as a whole. To make this practical, consider a principle of valuation. In the world, an object's value is primarily determined by what someone is willing to pay. An artist may claim his painting is worth a million dollars, but the actual monetary value comes when someone buys it. Thus, for fine art, furniture, and other expensive collectibles, records show how much it sold for as a means to gauge the value. Consider the value that we have as individuals, based on what the Father and the Son together were willing to pay for us. Reflect on the incomparable worth of the blood of the perfect and sinless Son of God. Ponder the Creator's supreme act of condescension in donning the form of a flesh-and-blood human and then giving that life as payment. Rather than allowing us to receive the wages of our sin, He paid that debt with a currency impossible for a human to assess, which gives us some idea of our value to God. Next, we should apply this incomparable value to someone else in the Body with whom we feel a close connection—perhaps a spouse or a good friend. God paid the same price for him or her because that individual incurred the same debt. Consider the value the Father and the Son now place on him or her based on what They were willing to pay. Finally, we must take this exercise one step further. Perhaps there is some part of the Body—maybe someone in our own congregation—whom we know we should love but do not like very much. Consider the value we place on him or her, then consider the price the Father and Son have already paid for that person. How does our valuation compare with God's? Or is it more comfortable to regard some as outside the Body than to be partial to them (as 'discern'—diakrino—indicates)? By not discerning the Body of Christ correctly, that is, by esteeming some members and despising others, the Corinthians were, in effect, signifying that Christ's blood—the life of the very Creator!—was worth more when it came to some parts of the Body than to others. Thus, Paul warns in I Corinthians 11:27-29, if they were not properly discerning the whole Body in their conduct throughout the year, they stood in grave danger because they would be unable to value and appreciate Christ's sacrifice in their fellowship with Him through the Passover. In not recognizing the God-given and inestimable worth of all the others in Christ, they were diminishing Christ! Just a few chapters before, Paul had written, "But when you thus sin against the brethren, and wound their weak conscience, you sin against Christ" (I Corinthians 8:12; emphasis ours). The result of taking the Passover unworthily is that we come under judgment. As Paul points out, the sickness and premature death that God judged "many" with (I Corinthians 11:30) resulted from their making an improper distinction about—and being partial to—the Body of believers. (Note that in Greek, "judgment" here does not indicate condemnation.) That judgment includes the removal of protection, even as God did not protect the Israelites in Egypt from the death angel if they were not under the blood of the Passover lamb. Paul does not imply that every illness or death has its source in an improper discernment of the Body. In John 9:3, Jesus reveals that the man's blindness resulted not from his or his parents' sin but to display the works of God in him. Sometimes, the "sins of society" lead more directly to disease rather than our own sins. Even so, numerous examples exist of God striking His servants (or their family members) with sickness or even death for certain sins. Even Paul (as Saul) was "judged" with blindness for a time for His persecution of the Body! Thus, if we are not adequately judging ourselves (I Corinthians 11:31) about the value we place on all parts of His spiritual Body, and God deems it is time for Him to judge us instead (verses 29, 31), then partaking of Christ's sacrifice will not provide healing but the reverse. If we are in opposition to Christ through despising parts of His Body, His sacrifice will not be a blessing for us but more like a curse. His stripes will not heal us but rather indict us. Still, if God has to judge us for not discerning the Body, it is for our benefit, keeping us from actual condemnation: "But when we are judged, we are chastened by the Lord, that we may not be condemned with the world" (I Corinthians 11:32). It is impossible to appreciate and value the shed blood of the Savior at Passover while devaluing parts of His spiritual Body throughout the rest of the year. When observing the Passover, we must remember that just as we are in fellowship with Jesus Christ through symbolically eating and drinking of His sacrifice, we are also in fellowship with His spiritual Body. We need to keep in mind the value that He has placed on each of us through His redemption and the obligation we now have to value all the members of His Body.
David C. Grabbe
What Does 'Discerning the Lord's Body' Mean? (Part Three)
|
|
1 Corinthians 11:29-30
Understanding these verses requires scrutinizing the overall context. Paul sets the stage for his Passover instructions back in I Corinthians 5:7, where he identifies Jesus Christ as our Passover. However, he does not expand on the subject until I Corinthians 10:16-17: Is not the cup of blessing that we bless a sharing in the blood of Christ? Is not the bread that we break a sharing in the body of Christ? Because there is one bread, we who are many are one body, for we all share the one bread. (New English Translation) In verse 17, the King James Version and New King James Version identify the church as "one bread," which is true in a roundabout way, but it is not quite what the Greek text expresses. Verse 17 indicates that because there is only one "Bread of Life"—which John 6 identifies as Christ—everyone who shares or partakes of that One Bread becomes a single spiritual body. Then, Paul illustrates that we become one—unified—with whatever we partake of: Observe Israel after the flesh: Are not those who eat of the sacrifices partakers of the altar? What am I saying then? That an idol is anything, or what is offered to idols is anything? Rather, that the things which the Gentiles sacrifice they sacrifice to demons and not to God, and I do not want you to have fellowship with demons. You cannot drink the cup of the Lord and the cup of demons; you cannot partake of the Lord's table and of the table of demons. (I Corinthians 10:18-21) In other words, those physical Israelites who ate of the sacrifices were partakers of the altar, the main instrument of worship. By eating a share of the sacrifices, the Israelites placed themselves in fellowship with the object of their worship. As long as it was God's altar and the sacrifices were performed according to His instructions, the sacrifices played a meaningful part in true worship. But when the Israelites ate from the altar of another so-called god—meaning a demon—they then joined in fellowship with that demon. Paul says we cannot have it both ways. Either we can partake of the wine and bread, fellowshipping with Jesus Christ, or we can participate in what the demons have to offer—not both. The overall principle is that we become spiritually unified with whatever we partake of. When we individually partake of the cup of blessing and the bread at Passover, we become one with Jesus Christ. But more than one person partakes of the Passover symbols; the whole church does. Thus, everyone who partakes of these symbols also becomes one with Him. Because of this, the "Lord's body" is a collective noun, composed of those whom the Father called and are now in fellowship with Christ through symbolically sharing in His blood and His body.
David C. Grabbe
What Does 'Discerning the Lord's Body' Mean? (Part One)
|
|
1 Corinthians 11:29
Many Bibles' marginal references for this verse, as well as some interlinear Bibles, indicate that the translators have added the word "Lord's" to the text, assuming that Paul refers to Christ's human body. However, in the Greek text, the end of the verse simply reads "not discerning the body." The words "the body" can refer to several things that are not mutually exclusive. Paul could weave multiple threads through his writings, and at times, overlap them in profound ways. First, the chapter shows that some members in Corinth were confused about whether the congregational meals were the Lord's Supper. By trying to observe the Lord's Supper or Passover on just any occasion, the significance of the bread and the wine becomes muddled through familiarity and sheer repetition. Hence, if any bread throughout the year symbolized Jesus Christ's crucified body, church members would take the Passover in an unworthy manner because they would not see His sacrifice as distinct and set apart. For the symbol to continue to be meaningful, people must distinguish between the unleavened bread eaten on Passover and common, daily bread. Second, we can understand the phrase "not discerning the body" as a reference to the tortured, physical body of Jesus Christ. Thus, we participate in the Passover in an unworthy manner if we do not seriously and consciously acknowledge our sins, which made Christ's excruciating sacrifice necessary. He suffered crucifixion because of what we have done, and without consciousness of our sin and the wages—punishment—we have earned, His sacrifice loses its significance in our minds. Third, "the body" can refer to the spiritual Body of believers, the church. I Corinthians 10:16-17 teaches that what we partake of is what we become a part of. When we partake of the bread that symbolizes His body, we become a part of the spiritual Body of believers who are also "in Christ" and have the Father and the Son dwelling in them. I Corinthians 10 contains the first mention of this spiritual Body, and the rest of the chapter and chapter 11 are all about things related to interactions within the Body. Then chapter 12 gives the most lengthy and specific explanation of the Body analogy in the Bible. After that, chapters 13 and 14 continue expounding on the theme of relationships and interactions within the Body, even though the Body is not directly mentioned. So, when Paul talks about "the body" without defining exactly what he means, we must remember that it appears in the middle of a lengthy discourse on the spiritual Body. In light of this, what does it mean to "discern" the body? The English word discern means "to separate or distinguish by the eye or by the understanding" or "to see the difference between two or more things." It can mean "to judge" or even "to be partial to." The Greek word in I Corinthians 11:29, diakrino, means essentially the same thing: "to make a separation or a distinction" or "to evaluate between two or more things, and become partial to one." It can mean "to differentiate" and "decide." What I Corinthians 11:29 means, then, is that if we do not discern or make a correct distinction regarding the spiritual Body, we will partake of the Passover in an unworthy manner. The way that we "discern the Body" is to distinguish it in our minds from what is not part of the Body—the rest of humanity. It means to show partiality to the Body as a whole, rather than making distinctions within the Body. The Corinthians were making distinctions about people within the Body, and thus they highly esteemed some individuals among them and despised others. Thus, Paul warns them that, when it came time to observe the Passover, they were in danger of eating and drinking judgment to themselves because they were not being partial to Christ's spiritual Body as a whole. Put another way, they were not treating all church members—all the brethren for whom Christ died—with the highest respect.
David C. Grabbe
What Does 'Discerning the Lord's Body' Mean? (Part Two)
|
Start Your Day with Scripture
Begin your day with God's Word — the Berean brings Scripture and commentary every morning.
Join 150,000+ subscribers growing daily in God's Word.
|
|
